Effect of Different Shaping Angles on Endotracheal Intubation under Visual Laryngoscope for Beginners
-
摘要:
目的 比较4种不同塑形角度导管对初学者气管插管成功率及术后咽部并发症的影响。 方法 选取全麻下行腹腔镜胆囊切除的患者160例，ASA分级Ⅰ～II级，无困难气道病史，根据导管形态及尖端塑形角度随机分为4组：35°蕉形弯管组（A组），50°蕉形弯管组（B组），35°直管组（C组），50°直管组（D组），每组40例。全麻诱导后，初学者采用可视喉镜进行气管插管。记录4组患者喉镜暴露分级（Cormack-Lehane分级）、喉外按压情况、插管一次成功率及插管时间；记录麻醉诱导前（T0）、麻醉诱导药物注射结束（T1）、插管即刻（T2）、插管后1min（T3）患者的SPO2、HR、MAP；随访拔管后即刻及术后24 h咽部疼痛及声音嘶哑发生率。 结果 4组患者各时间点Cormack-Lehane分级、HR、MAP比较，差异无统计学意义（P > 0.05）。B组和D组需要喉外按压的例数、插管时间、插管1次成功率、术后即刻咽痛、术后即刻声音嘶哑发生率均低于A组和C组，差异有统计学意义（P < 0.05）。 结论 使用可视喉镜进行气管插管时，50°蕉形弯管及50°直管可以缩短插管时间，术后并发症少，无明显血流动力学波动。 Abstract:Objective To compare the effects of 4 different shaping angle tubes on the success rate of tracheal intubation and postoperative pharyngeal complications among anesthetic beginners. Methods 160 patients who underwent laparoscopic cholecystectomy under general anesthesia, with ASA classification I to II, no history of difficult airway, were randomly divided into 4 groups according to the catheter shape and tip shaping angle: 35°banana-shaped elbow group（A Group）, 50°banana-shaped bent pipe group（Group B）, 35°straight pipe group（Group C）, 50°straight pipe group（Group D）, with 40 cases in each group. After induction of general anesthesia, tracheal intubation is performed using a video laryngoscope. The Cormack-Lehane grade of laryngoscope exposure, external laryngeal compression, one-time success rate of intubation and intubation time were recorded. SPO2, HR and MAP were recorded before anesthesia induction（T0）, at the end of anesthesia induction drug injection（T1）, immediately after intubation（T2） and 1min after intubation（T3）. The incidence of pharyngeal pain and hoarseness immediately after extubation and 24 hours after operation were followed up. Results There were no statistically significant differences in Cormack-Lehane classification, HR, and MAP among the four groups of patients at each time point（P > 0.05）. The number of cases requiring external laryngeal compression, intubation time, first-time intubation success rate, immediate postoperative sore throat, and immediate postoperative hoarseness rates in Groups B and D were all lower than those in Groups A and C, and the differences were statistically significant（P < 0.05）. Conclusion When using video laryngoscope for tracheal intubation, 50°banana-shaped curved tube and 50°straight tube can shorten the intubation time, reduce postoperative complications, and have no obvious hemodynamic fluctuations. -
图 1 不同气管导管塑形实物图
A：35° 蕉形弯管；B：50° 蕉形弯管；C：35° 直管；D：50° 直管。
Figure 1. Shape of different tracheal tubes
表 1 4组患者一般资料比较（n = 40）
Table 1. Comparison of the general data among the four groups of patients（n = 40）
项目 A组 B组 C组 D组 F/χ2 P 男/女（例） 22/18 16/24 18/22 22/18 2.702 0.440 年龄（岁） 43.7±10.2 46.4±10.1 44.6±12.1 44.2±11.8 0.455 0.714 BMI（kg/m2） 22.8±1.8 23.0±2.8 23.0±2.7 22.6±2.1 0.195 0.899 Mallampati分级（Ⅰ/Ⅱ） 12/28 13/27 10/30 11/29 0.610 0.894 麻醉时间（min） 90.0±21.3 85.5±22.6 86.6±24.0 89.2.±27.0 0.317 0.813 手术时间（min） 79.0±17.4 74.7±20.1 73.1±21.2 76.2±22.4 0.609 0.610 
下载: 导出CSV
表 2 4组患者C-L分级、辅助喉外按压、一次插管次数、插管时间比较（n = 40）
Table 2. Comparison of CL classification，auxiliary external laryngeal compression，number of intubations at one time，and intubation time among the four groups of patients（n = 40）
项目 A组 B组 C组 D组 F/χ2 P C-L[Ⅰ/Ⅱ（n）] 8/32 4/36 5/35 7/33 1.961 0.581 辅助喉外按压[n（%）] 14（35.0） 5（12.5） 16（40.0） 3（7.5） 17.256 < 0.001* 插管时间（s） 65.6±11.4 45.5±8.7 64.8±10.1 48.1±8.4 47.389 < 0.001* 一次插管成功[n（%）] 17（42.5） 35（87.5） 15（37.5） 37（92.5） 44.396 < 0.001* *P < 0.05。
下载: 导出CSV
表 3 4组患者不同时间点MAP的比较（$\bar x \pm s$，mmHg）
Table 3. Comparison of MAP at different time points among the four groups of patients （$ \bar x \pm s $，mmHg）
组别 T0 T1 T2 T3 A组（n=40） 91.1±8.0 80.5±7.9 87.3±8.1 76.2±7.8 B组（n=40） 91.1±7.5 81.7±11.9 84.8±9.7 78.2±10.2 C组（n=40） 89.9±11.1 85.0±10.5 83.6±10.1 78.8±10.3 D组（n=40） 91.4±9.8 84.6±10.2 85.5±9.0 80.1±9.2 F 1.077 1.875 1.165 1.187 P 0.361 0.136 0.325 0.317
下载: 导出CSV
表 4 4组患者不同时间点的HR比较（$ \bar x \pm s $，次/min）
Table 4. Comparison of HR at different time points among the four groups of patients （$ \bar x \pm s $，times/min）
组别 T0 T1 T2 T3 A组（n=40） 72.6±9.9 72.5±6.8 83.5±8.0 73.1±7.3 B组（n=40） 72.1±12.3 74.1±10.3 83.4±7.6 69.8±7.3 C组（n=40） 74.7±11.0 76.5±9.4 85.9±8.1 72.2±10.3 D组（n=40） 75.4±10.9 75.8±9.8 84.3±9.1 75.1±10.2 F 0.841 1.511 0.668 2.428 P 0.473 0.214 0.573 0.068
下载: 导出CSV
表 5 4组患者术后咽痛发生情况比较[n（%）]
Table 5. Comparison of the occurrence of postoperative sore throat among the four groups of patients [n（%）]
时间点 A组（n=40） B组（n=40） C组（n=40） D组（n=40） χ2 P 拔管后即刻咽痛 19（47.5） 6（15.0） 16（40.0） 5（12.5） 18.185 < 0.001* 拔管后24 h咽痛 4（10.0） 1（2.5） 2（5.0） 1（2.5） 3.158 0.368 拔管后即刻声音嘶哑 10（25.0） 2（5.0） 9（22.5） 3（7.5） 9.804 0.020* 拔管后即刻声音嘶哑 2（5.0） 0（0.0） 1（2.5） 1（2.5） 2.051 0.562 *P < 0.05。
下载: 导出CSV
-
[1] Lim H, Cha Y B, Ryu K H, et al. Comparison of two different shapes of stylets for intubation with the McGrath MAC® video laryngoscope: A randomized controlled trial[J]. Journal of International Medical Research, 2020, 48（10）: 300060520962951. [2] Gupta A,Singh P,Gupta N,et al. Comparative efficacy of C-MAC Miller videolaryngoscope versus McGrathMAC size "1" video laryngoscope in neonates and infants undergoing surgical procedures under general anesthesia: A prospective randomized controlled trial[J]. Paediatric Anaesthesia,2021,31(10):1089-1096. doi: 10.1111/pan.14244 [3] 陈 齐,高志伟,刘岳鑫,等. “J”型塑形气管导管不同向上弯曲长度对可视喉镜引导下气管插管的影响[J]. 西南医科大学学报,2017,40(6):547-550. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.2096-3351.2017.06.007 [4] Hung T Y,Lin L W,Yeh Y H,et al. The evaluation of a better intubation strategy when only the epiglottis is visible: A randomized,cross-over mannequin study[J]. BMC Anesthesiol,2019,19(1):8. doi: 10.1186/s12871-018-0663-9 [5] Varela M L,Carmo M J,Lares A. Cormack-Lehane grading evolution to assess trainee's progress in laryngoscopy[J]. Postgraduate Medical Journal,2018,94(1114):479-479. doi: 10.1136/postgradmedj-2018-135926 [6] Pujari V S,Thiyagarajan B,Annamalai A,et al. A comparative study in airway novices using king vision videolaryngoscope and conventional macintosh direct laryngoscope for endotracheal intubation[J]. Anesthesia,Essays and Researches,2021,15(1):57-61. doi: 10.4103/aer.aer_72_21 [7] Hosalli V,Arjun B K,Ambi U,et al. Comparison of Airtraq™,McCoy™ and Macintosh laryngoscopes for endotracheal intubation in patients with cervical spine immobilisation: A randomised clinical trial[J]. Indian Journal of Anaesthesia,2017,61(4):332-337. doi: 10.4103/ija.IJA_517_16 [8] Singh P,Srivastava V,Gautam S,et al. A randomized controlled trial comparing Macintosh laryngoscope and Airtraq video laryngoscope for endotracheal intubation in patients with thyroid swelling: Competing the convention[J]. Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care,2022,11(7):3699-3704. doi: 10.4103/jfmpc.jfmpc_2454_21 [9] Dagli R,Canturk M,Celik F,et al. The role of videolaryngoscope in endotracheal intubation training programs[J]. Brazilian Journal of Anesthesiology,2018,68(5):447-454. doi: 10.1016/j.bjan.2018.02.008 [10] Huang P,Zhou R,Lu Z,et al. GlideScope® versus C-MAC®(D) videolaryngoscope versus macintosh laryngoscope for double lumen endotracheal intubation in patients with predicted normal airways: A randomized,controlled,prospective trial[J]. BMC Anesthesiology,2020,20(1):119. doi: 10.1186/s12871-020-01012-y [11] 吴朝萌,郑剑桥,刘斌. 对麻醉实习医师进行不同插管喉镜气管插管的教学效果比较[J]. 解放军预防医学杂志,2019,37(8):93-95. doi: 10.13704/j.cnki.jyyx.2019.08.043 [12] 刘冬梅,莫怀忠,易强林. 初学者使用环状弯曲与管芯塑形气管导管在预期非困难气道患者中的效果比较[J]. 临床麻醉学杂志,2022,38(8):841-845. doi: 10.12089/jca.2022.08.013 [13] Jaber S,Rolle A,Godet T,et al. Effect of the use of an endotracheal tube and stylet versus an endotracheal tube alone on first-attempt intubation success: A multicentre,randomised clinical trial in 999 patients[J]. Intensive Care Medicine,2021,47(6):653-664. [14] Tosh P,Rajan S,Kumar L. Ease of intubation with C-MAC videolaryngoscope: Use of 60° angled styletted endotracheal tube versus intubation over bougie[J]. Anesthesia Essays & Researches,2018,12(1):194-198. [15] 李楠,崔晓岗,孙双春,等. 复方利多卡因乳膏联合达克罗宁胶浆改善气管插管不良反应的效果[J]. 实用临床医药杂志,2022,26(10):92-96. [16] Bilgi M,Velioglu Y,Yoldas H,et al. Effects of lidocaine oropharyngeal spray applied before endotracheal intubation on QT bispersion in patients undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting: A prospective randomized controlled study[J]. Brazilian Journal of Cardiovascular Surgery,2020,35(3):291-298. -
点击查看大图
图(1) / 表(5)
计量
- 文章访问数: 627
- HTML全文浏览量: 450
- PDF下载量: 5
- 被引次数: 0
