Comparative Analysis of the Efficacy of Neuroendoscopic and Microscopic Transnasal Resection of Pituitary Tumours in the Pterygoid Region
-
摘要:
目的 探讨神经内镜和显微镜下经鼻蝶垂体腺瘤切除术治疗垂体腺瘤的临床疗效。 方法 回顾性分析2019年1月至2023年12月昆明医科大学第一附属医院神经外科治疗的150例垂体腺瘤患者的临床资料,按手术方式分为显微镜组(n = 100)和神经内镜组(n = 50),比较2种手术方式对垂体腺瘤的临床疗效。 结果 2组手术患者中,Knosp分级0~Ⅱ级的全切率神经内镜组(97.6%)和显微镜组(95.1%)差异无统计学意义(P > 0.05),Knosp分级Ⅲ~Ⅳ级的全切率神经内镜组(66.7%)明显高于显微镜组(10.5%),术后住院时间、原发症状改善率神经内镜组优于显微镜组,差异有统计学意义( P < 0.05)。手术时间显微镜组略短于神经内镜组,术中大流量脑脊液漏发生率、术中出血量、术后激素水平变化、术后并发症发生率2组均差异无统计学意义( P > 0.05)。 结论 2种手术方式对于垂体腺瘤患者均有较好的治疗效果,对于KnospⅢ~Ⅳ级的垂体腺瘤全切率,神经内镜高于显微镜,临床上还需根据肿瘤的分型及患者的一般情况等来选择最适合患者的手术方式。 Abstract:Objective To analyze the clinical effectiveness of neuroendoscopy and microscopy in the treatment of hypophysectomy. Methods The clinical data of 150 patients with pituitary adenoma treated in the Department of Neurosurgery, the First Affiliated Hospital of Kunming Medical University from January 2019 to December 2023 were retrospectively analyzed. According to the surgical methods, they were divided into the microscope group ( n = 100 ) and the neuroendoscopy group ( n = 50 ). The clinical efficacy of the two surgical methods on pituitary adenoma was compared. Results In the two groups of surgical patients, there was no significant difference between the total incision rate of Knosp grade 0-II in the neuroendoscopy group (97.6%) and the microscopy group (95.1%), the total incision rate of Knosp grade III-IV in the neuroendoscopy group (66.7%) was significantly higher than that of the microscopy group (10.5%), The postoperative hospital stay and the rate of improvement of primary symptoms were better in the neuroendoscopic group than in the microscopic group, and the difference was highly significant (P < 0.05). There was no significant difference in rates of CSF leak, hemorrhage, hormonal changes, or complications between these two groups ( P > 0.05). Conclusion Both surgical methods have good therapeutic effects on patients with pituitary adenomas. For Knosp grade III to IV pituitary adenomas, the total resection rate is higher with neuroendoscopy than with microscopy. The clinical decision to use either technique depends on the type of tumor and the patient's general condition. -
Key words:
- Pituitary adenomas /
- Endoscope /
- Microscope /
- Efficacy comparison
-
表 1 患者基线资料[( $\bar x \pm s $)/n(%)]
Table 1. Baseline data of patients [( $\bar x \pm s $)/n(%)]
项目 显微镜组(n=100) 神经内镜组(n=50) χ2/t P 性别 男 48(48.0) 25(50.0) 0.053 0.817 女 52(52.0) 25(50.0) 年龄(岁) 41.59±11.49 49.14±13.17 −3.451 0.001* Knosp 0~Ⅱ级 81(81.0) 41(82.0) 0.022 0.882 KnospⅢ~Ⅳ级 19(19.0) 9(18.0) 肿瘤分型 泌乳素型 40(40.0) 11(22.0) 5.440 0.142 生长激素型 15(15.0) 8(16.0) ACTH型 4(4.0) 2(4.0) 无功能型 41(41.0) 29(58.0) *P < 0.05。 表 2 术后观察指标[( $\bar x \pm s $)/n(%)]
Table 2. Postoperative observation indexes[( $\bar x \pm s $)/n(%)]
术后观察指标 显微镜组(n=100) 神经内镜组(n=50) χ2/t P 肿瘤全切例数 79(79.0) 46(92.0) 4.056 0.044* Knosp 0~Ⅱ级全切 77(95.1) 40(97.6) 0.433 0.511 KnospⅢ~Ⅳ级全切 2(10.5) 6(66.7) 9.432 0.002* 术后并发症发生例数 13(13.0) 4(8.0) 0.829 0.362 术前症状改善例数 79(79.0) 47(94.0) 5.580 0.018* 术中大流量脑脊液漏 22(22.0) 7(14.0) 1.368 0.242 手术时间(h) 1.722±0.585 1.820±0.471 −1.105 0.271 术中出血量(mL) 58.35±22.84 64.80±29.78 −1.469 0.144 术后住院时间(d) 11.89±3.47 6.86±2.38 9.222 <0.001* *P < 0.05。 表 3 术前术后激素水平变化[( $\bar x \pm s $)/n(%)]
Table 3. Changes of hormone levels before and after operation[( $\bar x \pm s $)/n(%)]
时间 显微镜组(n=100) 神经内镜组(n=50) χ2/t P 泌乳素型术前(ng/mL) 125.57±21.83 136.35±46.33 −0.211 0.836 泌乳素型术后(ng/mL) 30.79±6.0 29.43±16.71 0.077 0.940 χ2/t 4.185 2.171 P <0.001* 0.001* 生长激素术前(ng/mL) 41.18±7.38 120.95±71.24 −1.114 0.301 生长激素术后(ng/mL) 7.44±2.49 15.82±9.22 −0.878 0.405 χ2/t 4.333 1.463 P <0.001* 0.069 ACTH术前(ng/mL) 109.00±10.58 113.50±23.34 −0.260 0.832 ACTH术后(ng/mL) 7.55±1.88 7.95±4.31 −0.125 0.918 χ2/t 18.875 6.290 P 0.046* 0.024* *P < 0.05。 -
[1] Albano,L,Losa,M,Barzaghi,L R ,et al. Benign and malignant tumors of the pituitary gland[J]. Adv Exp Med Biol,2023,1405:281-297. [2] 周肯游. 神经导航在经鼻侵袭性垂体瘤垂体瘤切除术中的临床应用[D]. 昆明: 昆明医科大学,2022. [3] Saeger,W. The 2017 WHO classification of pituitary tumors[J]. Pathologe,2021,42(3):333-351. doi: 10.1007/s00292-021-00932-x [4] Tritos,N A,Miller,K K. Diagnosis and management of pituitary adenomas: A review[J]. Jama-J Am Med Assoc,2023,329(16):1386-1398. doi: 10.1001/jama.2023.5444 [5] Gupta,T,Chatterjee,A. Modern Radiation therapy for pituitary adenoma: Review of techniques and outcomes[J]. Neurol India.,2020,68(Supple):S113-S122. [6] Byun,Y H,Kang,H,Kim,Y H. Advances in pituitary surgery[J]. Endocrinol Metab.,2022,37(4):608-616. doi: 10.3803/EnM.2022.1546 [7] 赵浥,王希,魏栋,等. 显微镜及神经内镜经鼻蝶窦手术治疗垂体瘤垂体瘤的对比研究[J]. 临床神经外科杂志,2022,19(5):538-542. [8] 叶小健,冯士军,张春阳,等. 垂体瘤垂体瘤治疗的研究进展[J]. 现代临床医学,2022,48(6):465-467,476. [9] Guan,X,Wang,Y,Zhang,C,et al. Surgical experience of transcranial approaches to large-to-giant pituitary adenomas in knosp grade 4[J]. Front Endocrinol (Lausanne),2022,13:857314. [10] Hardy J. Transphenoidal microsurgery of the normal and pathological pituitary[J]. Clin Neurosurg,1969,16(185-217. [11] Kayama,T,Kuge,A. Neuroendoscopic surgery-current state and future development[J]. Nihon Rinsho,2010,68(7):1366-1370. [12] Bajaj J,Chandra P S. Recent developments in endoscopicendonasal approach for pituitary adenomas[J]. Neurol India,2020,68(Supple):S79-S84. [13] 谭宝东,崔连旭,赵庆顺,等. 显微镜与神经内镜下经单侧鼻蝶入路手术治疗垂体瘤垂体瘤的效果及并发症[J]. 中国肿瘤临床与康复,2019,26(4):446-449. [14] 李萍,刘国良. 垂体瘤的分类及早期诊断[J]. 中国实用内科杂志,2002,22(5):257-260. [15] Wu ZB. The shift of therapeutic strategy for prolactinomas: Surgery as the first-line option[J]. Nat Rev Endocrinol,2024,20(5):310. doi: 10.1038/s41574-024-00953-5 [16] Liu H,Zhou Y,Chen,Y,et al. Treatment outcomes of neuroendoscopic and microscopic trans-sphenoidal pituitary adenomectomies and the effects on hormone levels[J]. Minerva Surg.,2023,78(5):518-524. [17] 吴波,陈崇毅,杨威,等. 内镜与显微镜下经鼻蝶窦手术治疗垂体瘤垂体瘤的效果及对患者激素水平及视觉功能的影响[J]. 实用癌症杂志,2020,34(8):1284-1287. [18] Huang,Y,Zheng,T,Liu,Y,et al. Comparison of microscopic transsphenoidal surgery and neuroendoscopic transsphenoidal surgery in pituitary adenoma resection and the risk factors of postoperative cerebrospinal fluid leakage[J]. Am J Transl Res,2023,15(7):4746-4754. [19] Rotenberg,B,Tam,S,Ryu,WH,et al. Microscopic versus endoscopic pituitary surgery: A systematic review[J]. Laryngoscope,2010,120(7):1292-1297. doi: 10.1002/lary.20949 [20] 贺虎,王飞,凌士营. 经鼻蝶神经内镜与显微镜下切除垂体瘤垂体瘤的安全性与疗效对比[J]. 立体定向和功能性神经外科杂志,2022,35(1):12-17. [21] 陈露露. 神经内镜与神经导航辅助显微镜下经鼻蝶入路垂体瘤垂体瘤切除术的临床疗效对比[D]. 蚌埠: 蚌埠医学院,2017. [22] Xu,Z Q,Su,C B,Wang,R Z,et al. Clinical application of neuronavigation in transsphenoidal microsurgery of pituitary adenomas[J]. Zhonghua Wai Ke Za Zhi,2011,49(8):707-711. -